top of page
  • Writer's pictureHeather Green

How to Make this Pumpkintini that Tastes just like Pie!

Updated: Dec 23, 2023

I’M THANKFUL FOR MARTINI’S! No matter how big or small your Thanksgiving is this year, there’s one thing you can’t forget, and that’s the pumpkin pie. However, this is 2020, and nothing is really as it seems, so if that’s the order of the day, then this Pumpkintini should fit the bill! It’s simple to make and tastes just like a slice of that iconic pie!


I’m not too fond of when I get a martini, and it burns the back of my throat. That’s what I was fully prepared to experience here. Imagine how surprised I was when I took a sip and had all the best flavors of a pumpkin pie with none of that burn! I could have had five of these, but honestly, with the amount of alcohol in this, one was enough.

To help you make this gorgeous drink, I’m going to link you to a few items. These are affiliate links, which means if you click on one and buy something, I will get a small commission. Thank you.

If you are looking to make drinks more frequently, a good investment would be a bar set. They come with various things, but most iconically is the shaker, which you will definitely need for this recipe. The other ingredients are as follows:

How to Make this Pumpkintini that Tastes just like Pie! by

A good quality shaker!

4 Tablespoons of Pumpkin Spice Liqueur

3 Tablespoons Caramel Irish Cream

3 Tablespoons Cream or Milk

1 Tablespoon Vanilla Vodka

1 Tablespoon Amaretto

and Whipped cream and a dash of Cinnamon (optional) as the garnish.

How to Make this Pumpkintini that Tastes just like Pie! by

Super easy, fill up your shaker with ice and add everything except the toppings. Shake it up, and when it’s too cold to hold, you know you’re ready to pour. I like to use the whipped cream with a nozzle so that it looks pretty on top. Add a sprinkle of Cinnamon, and you’re ready to serve! I think you’ll be surprised at how smooth it goes down. So if you have a family member who may not want a slice of pie, but may like a drink, suggest this and then get ready to impress.

How to Make this Pumpkintini that Tastes just like Pie! by

If you made this and want to let me know your thoughts, please message me in the comments below. I LOVE hearing from my readers. If you want me to see what you made, please tag me on my social media (Facebook and Instagram are my most used). Lastly, if you would like to be kept up to date with future posts, please click HERE and sign up! As always, I wish you a beautiful day. -Heather Astaneh

bottom of page